Come on, let's get our teeth into a controversy that's worth the time and effort (sorry, I'm being facetious). The headline reads:
Stephen King denigrates Stephanie Meyer (author of Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse and Breaking Dawn)
and other popular writers.
All of which seems awfully silly since they both write books that tweens and teenagers absolutely adore. I mean, since when do writers of horror or vampire novels talk like smug intellectuals? Lots of people read Harry Potter, Nancy Drew, the Goosebump books, etc. Does it matter if they're on anyone's Great Literature list or not? I mean, what's really going on here? Is King concerned about his legacy in three or four hundred years?
I have to say that it amuses me that the main focus of his attack, she of the Twilight books, is a namesake of the same saint as he. On the other hand, it doesn't amuse me that King wildly slams other writers with such cavalier disdain. Actually it's rather offensive. He must think awfully well of himself. I guess he thinks he is such a fabulously
good writer - that would be good in the sense of "of-the-ages" as opposed to successful and/or popular - that it's reasonable for him to assess and judge other writers, and throw the phrase "terrible writer" at some "very successful" writers like JK Rowling (Harry Potter), Erle Stanley Gardner (Perry Mason and others), Dean Koontz and James Patterson.
But wait a minute. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but isn't King also wildly successful? And when did any critic or academic ever suggest or imply that he's as "good" a writer as, say, Ovid or Addison or Thackeray or Trollope? Why does he think he's superior in objective and qualitative ways to other best selling and successful writers? In the interests of honesty, I have to acknowledge that I've no personal knowledge of his quality as a writer, so I'll more than willingly stipulate that he is phenomenally good. But how can even a really really good writer of horror fiction put his nose so ethereally high into the air and draw such negative comparisons with others and be so rude about it? (Keep in mind that the interview was given to a USA Today reporter so if he wants to get all high and mighty, there could be some aspersions cast as to
that rag's intellectual status, though only if we wanted to go there.)
The U.K.'s Guardian published an article today after
Stephen Kings' attack on Stephanie and the others. The good news is that now I know that the Twilight series is written by a Mormon and is about a vegetarian vampire.
Labels: madness, people of note, writing